Last Week in Space: Starship Tower Catch, Vulcan Anomaly, and Orbital Station Realignment (2026-11-17)

A pivotal week in aerospace: SpaceX achieves an upper-stage tower catch on Flight 15, ULA's Vulcan suffers an in-flight anomaly with Amazon Kuiper satellites, and commercial space station architectures face sharp realignment.

Share
Last Week in Space: Starship Tower Catch, Vulcan Anomaly, and Orbital Station Realignment (2026-11-17)
Photo by SpaceX / Unsplash

Executive Takeaway

The aerospace sector experienced a defining inflection point this past week, marked by contrasting extremes in heavy-lift launch reliability, commercial orbital infrastructure, and deep-space astrophysics. SpaceX achieved an unprecedented milestone in spaceflight reusability by executing the first pad capture of the Starship upper stage, validating full two-stage structural recovery at the launch mount. In contrast, United Launch Alliance suffered a critical mid-flight Centaur V anomaly that destroyed 40 operational Amazon Project Kuiper satellites, tightening Western medium-to-heavy lift capacity and disrupting constellation deployment timelines.

Simultaneously, the race to secure uninterrupted post-International Space Station (ISS) orbital presence entered a tumultuous phase. Blue Origin's formal withdrawal from NASA's Commercial Low Earth Orbit Destinations (CLD) Phase 2 procurement, coupled with unsealed intellectual property litigation between Axiom Space and Vast, underscores growing commercial friction and capital concentration ahead of the 2030 ISS retirement cliff. Across international and scientific domains, ESA cataloged 900 million galaxies via Euclid, the Hera probe reached the DART impact site, and China demonstrated expanding diplomatic reach by slotting Pakistan's first astronaut onto the Shenzhou-24 manifest.


Curated Weekly Aerospace Stories

1. SpaceX Completes First Orbital Tower Catch of Starship Upper Stage (Flight 15)

SpaceX conducted Flight 15 of its integrated Starship launch vehicle from Starbase in Boca Chica, Texas. Following nominal stage separation, the Super Heavy booster executed a controlled soft water touchdown test in the Gulf of Mexico. Meanwhile, the Starship second stage reached its designated orbital trajectory, deployed test mass simulators and Starlink dispenser fixtures, demonstrated an in-space Raptor engine re-light, and executed a precision re-entry burn over its designated atmospheric corridor. After approximately 22 hours in phased orbit, Starship returned to the launch site, where the orbital launch mount mechanical arms ("chopsticks") at Pad B captured the vehicle mid-air. [Source]

Technical Assessment: Recovering both stages directly at the pad eliminates landing gear mass penalties and marine recovery refurbishment delays, directly supporting the high-cadence tanker flights required for NASA's Artemis Human Landing System (HLS) propellant depots. However, high thermal-aerodynamic stress on pad catch dampers and pending FAA environmental evaluations remain critical pacing items before rapid commercial turnaround can be certified.

2. ULA Vulcan Centaur Fails Mid-Flight, Destroying 40 Amazon Project Kuiper Satellites

A United Launch Alliance (ULA) Vulcan Centaur rocket suffered a critical upper-stage anomaly roughly 10 minutes post-launch from Space Launch Complex 41 (SLC-41) at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station. The mission, carrying 40 operational broadband satellites for Amazon’s Low Earth Orbit (LEO) Project Kuiper constellation, experienced an uncontained failure during the Centaur V upper stage’s second RL10 burn. The vehicle and payload re-entered the atmosphere, resulting in a total mission loss—ULA’s first in over two decades of corporate operations. [Source]

Technical Assessment: With Amazon holding 38 contracted Vulcan launches to meet FCC constellation deployment deadlines (requiring 50% orbital fielding by mid-decade), this failure strains the Western launch supply chain. Root-cause investigations focusing on Centaur V turbomachinery or propellant lines temporarily halt upcoming National Security Space Launch (NSSL) certifications pending joint USAF-ULA board findings.

3. ESA Releases Milestone Euclid Survey Cataloging Over 900 Million Galaxies

The European Space Agency (ESA) issued its first major cosmological data release from the Euclid space telescope, positioned at the Sun-Earth Lagrange Point 2 (L2). Integrating wide-survey and deep-field sectors across optical and near-infrared instruments, the catalog documents over 900 million galaxies and quasars with high astrometric precision. The resulting dataset produces the largest 3D cosmic map to date, tracing matter distribution and weak gravitational lensing across 10 billion years of cosmic history. [Source]

Technical Assessment: Euclid’s precise cosmic shear and baryon acoustic oscillation metrics directly probe dark energy and dark matter, testing general relativity on cosmological scales and addressing tensions in Hubble constant measurements. Onboard de-icing thermal routines continue to successfully manage secondary optical condensation with minimal impact on observational duty cycles.

4. Blue Origin Withdraws Orbital Reef Station Bid from NASA Commercial LEO Destinations

Blue Origin leadership confirmed that the company will not submit an independent proposal for Phase 2 of NASA’s Commercial Low Earth Orbit Destinations (CLD) procurement program. Blue Origin had previously collaborated with Sierra Space on the "Orbital Reef" concept. The company is reallocating engineering and program capital toward the New Glenn heavy-lift launcher, the Blue Ring orbital logistics platform, and the Blue Moon National Team human landing system under Artemis. [Source]

Technical Assessment: The withdrawal concentrates NASA's options among competing station concepts from Axiom Space, Vast, and Voyager Space/Starlab. With the ISS planned for retirement around 2030, rising private development costs and uncertain commercial microgravity demand heighten risks for continuous Western sovereign presence in low Earth orbit.

5. ESA’s Hera Probe Commences Close-Range Proximity Operations at Didymos-Dimorphos

The European Space Agency confirmed that its Hera planetary defense probe has successfully navigated into close-proximity inspection orbits around the binary asteroid system (65803) Didymos and its moonlet Dimorphos. Operating at ranges between 25 and 30 kilometers, Hera initiated high-resolution optical and thermal mapping to inspect the impact crater and structural deformations resulting from NASA’s DART kinetic impactor test conducted in 2022. [Source]

Technical Assessment: Hera’s close-range characterization will measure the precise momentum transfer enhancement factor (β), determining whether DART excavated a localized crater or globally reshuffled Dimorphos’s rubble-pile interior, transitioning planetary defense modeling into deterministic kinetic deflection engineering.

6. JWST Detects 'Forbidden' Rotational Transitions of Trihydrogen Cation (H3+)

Astrophysicists utilizing the Mid-Infrared Instrument (MIRI) aboard the James Webb Space Telescope recorded the first direct spectral detection of pure rotational "forbidden" transitions of the trihydrogen cation (H3+). Resolved within shocked, heavily irradiated circumstellar gas disks surrounding young protostars, these transitions occur where extreme non-equilibrium conditions bypass standard quantum mechanical selection rules. [Source]

Technical Assessment: Because H3+ initiates cosmic gas-phase organic reaction networks leading to prebiotic molecules, these rotational spectral lines offer a sensitive tracer for cosmic-ray ionization rates and gas temperatures in actively forming protoplanetary systems.

7. ISRO Validates Upgraded PSLV Third Stage Solid Motor in Static Firing

The Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) successfully completed a full-duration static qualification test of the re-engineered solid propellant third stage (PS3) of its Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle (PSLV) at the Satish Dhawan Space Centre (SDSC-SHAR) in Sriharikota. The test validated a modified composite nozzle divergent section and revised propellant casting insulation profiles designed to eliminate thermal and pressure anomalies noted in prior flights. [Source]

Technical Assessment: The PSLV remains India's premier commercial workhorse for earth observation and rideshare smallsats. Restoring PS3 stage qualification clears the pipeline for upcoming sovereign and foreign payload deployments across SSO and polar orbits.

8. Pakistani Astronaut Designated for Shenzhou-24 Flight to China’s Tiangong Station

The China Manned Space Agency (CMSA) and Pakistan’s Space and Upper Atmosphere Research Commission (SUPARCO) finalized crew integration for the upcoming Shenzhou-24 mission to the Tiangong space station. An active Pakistani military pilot completed extravehicular simulation and centrifuge protocols at the Astronaut Center of China in Beijing, marking the first time a foreign national will crew a Chinese orbital spacecraft and reside aboard Tiangong. [Source]

Technical Assessment: The deployment highlights CMSA’s operational maturity and expanding multilateral space partnerships. By offering orbital access outside the Artemis Accords framework, China continues to develop an alternative human spaceflight alliance ahead of the ISS transition.

9. Thales Alenia Space and ESA Advance QINSAT Quantum Communications Project

Thales Alenia Space and ESA finalized contract amendments establishing specialized hardware integration laboratories at CNES facilities for the Quantum Interconnect Satellite (QINSAT) initiative. Concurrently published operational baseline models indicate expected space-to-ground quantum key distribution (QKD) yields of approximately 90 entangled photon pairs per ground station pass over a 331-second optical line-of-sight window. [Source]

Technical Assessment: Orbital quantum entanglement distribution provides cryptographic security resilient against quantum decryption attacks. The 90-pair per pass baseline illustrates ongoing challenges involving atmospheric scattering, pointing jitter, and cloud cover that require high-precision adaptive optics at receiving optical ground stations.

10. NASA Expands CLPS 2 Lunar Logistics Framework and Awards Nuclear Rover Delivery

NASA formalized onboarding under its follow-on Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS 2) Indefinite Delivery/Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ) contract, establishing a shared $10 billion ceiling across eight commercial aerospace vendors through 2036. Alongside framework execution, NASA awarded a $94 million task order to Blue Origin to deliver the nuclear radioisotope-powered PROMISE rover to the lunar South Pole to prospect for volatile water ice inside permanently shadowed craters. [Source]

Technical Assessment: The transition to CLPS 2 reflects institutional adoption of commercial service acquisitions for high-mass lunar infrastructure. Transporting radioisotope thermoelectric systems demands rigorous launch safety certifications and autonomous hazard-avoidance navigation over polar terrain.

11. Axiom Space Files False Claims Act Lawsuit Against Commercial Station Rival Vast

Court filings unsealed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas revealed that Axiom Space has filed a False Claims Act lawsuit against commercial space station competitor Vast. Axiom alleges that Vast improperly obtained, modified, and submitted proprietary Axiom engineering models, module interconnect designs, and safety protocols in its bidding for NASA Commercial LEO Destinations (CLD) awards. [Source]

Technical Assessment: As NASA prepares to award multi-billion-dollar Phase 2 commercial habitat contracts, federal litigation and potential inspector general scrutiny present procurement risks that could delay commercial station deployments needed before the ISS de-orbit schedule.


This week’s developments illustrate three overarching strategic macro shifts across the global space economy:

  • Launch Reusability vs. Disposable Fleet Fragility: SpaceX's successful Flight 15 upper-stage tower catch validates the architectural path toward full two-stage reusability, driving orbital delivery marginal costs downward. Conversely, the Vulcan Centaur failure highlights the systemic vulnerability of global satellite constellation operators who rely on constrained, non-reusable medium-to-heavy lift providers.
  • Commercial LEO Transition Friction: The commercial space station ecosystem is experiencing intense structural pressure. Blue Origin’s withdrawal from CLD Phase 2, combined with legal confrontation between Axiom and Vast, highlights the harsh reality of building private orbital infrastructure: massive upfront capital expenditure paired with an unproven non-governmental customer base.
  • Multilateral Orbital Geopolitics: With Pakistan integrating into the Shenzhou-24 mission, human spaceflight diplomacy is increasingly bifurcating into two competing architectures: the US-led Artemis and commercial LEO ecosystem, and China's Tiangong and International Lunar Research Station (ILRS) network.

Practical Implications for Engineers, Defense Planners & Founders

  • For Propulsion & Launch Systems Engineers: Scrutinize cryogenic upper-stage turbomachinery and propellant feedline dynamics during vacuum relights. The Centaur V failure reinforces that upper-stage restart reliability under low-gravity thermal equilibrium remains one of the highest-risk flight regimes in expendable and reusable architectures alike.
  • For Satellite Constellation Program Managers: Reassess launch manifest multi-sourcing and contract milestones. Operators reliant on single launch architectures face significant regulatory exposure when mid-decade deployment quotas are challenged by grounding events.
  • For National Security & Space Defense Planners: Accelerate operational quantum key distribution (QKD) and optical crosslink testing. As demonstrated by the QINSAT lab milestones, sovereign tamper-proof downlinks require robust adaptive optics ground networks to offset atmospheric signal degradation.
  • For Aerospace Startup Founders & Investors: Focus on commercial lunar and orbital logistics where federal anchor demand is codified. NASA's $10B CLPS 2 IDIQ framework proves sustained institutional procurement for lunar surface delivery, while independent orbital stations face tightening private capital requirements.

What to Watch in the Coming Week

  • Centaur V Anomaly Investigation: Initial telemetry readouts and preliminary findings from the joint USAF-ULA mishap investigation board on the RL10 upper-stage shutdown.
  • Starship Flight 15 Post-Flight Inspections: Engineering analysis of Pad B mechanical catch dampers, thermal barrier wear, and upper-stage structural integrity following the high-energy tower catch.
  • Hera Prox-Ops Science Returns: First optical and thermal imagery streams from ESA's Hera spacecraft detailing the Dimorphos crater structure.
  • CLD Phase 2 Evaluation Windows: NASA responses to private sector alignment following Blue Origin's withdrawal and the Axiom-Vast legal proceedings.